Recharge owns online Shopify subscriptions: deep tooling, priced like it, with a monthly fee plus per-order fees. MemberZone plays a different field: in-person and omnichannel, adding memberships, subscriptions, and loyalty that ring up at the POS, with no monthly platform fee. Pure online Shopify brand? Recharge is the specialist. Business that lives at a physical POS? MemberZone, which runs beside Shopify with its own storefront.
Which is right for you
Skip the spreadsheet. Here's the honest call.
Choose MemberZone if…
- Your business runs through a physical POS, not only an online store
- You want memberships and loyalty at the point of sale
- You'd rather avoid monthly and per-order fees
Choose Recharge if…
- You're a pure-online Shopify DTC brand
- Native Shopify subscription tooling is your core need
Capability scorecard
Line by line, no hand-waving
MemberZone leads on 2 of 5 buyer priorities below. The rest is an honest read of where each tool lands.
| Capability | MemberZone | Recharge |
|---|---|---|
| Best channel | In-person and omnichannel (native Square and Toast) | Online Shopify storefront |
| Monthly fee + per-order fees | No monthly fee on Starter & Growth; percentage of membership volume (flat monthly at Enterprise) | Monthly fee plus per-order and percentage fees |
| Shopify online subscriptions | No Shopify connection; its own storefront for signups and member orders | Deep, native Shopify subscription tooling |
| Memberships & loyalty at the POS | Memberships and member rewards on the register | Online subscriptions; not POS loyalty |
| Fulfillment & pickup | Carrier labels, pickup, and compliance shipping | Online order fulfillment via Shopify |
Where Recharge wins
An honest look.
No tool wins every dimension. Here is where Recharge is the better fit.
Recharge is purpose-built for online Shopify subscriptions, with the deepest integration, churn tooling, and app ecosystem in that lane.
For a pure-online DTC brand with no physical POS, Recharge (or another Shopify-native app) is the more natural fit than a POS-first platform.
Why teams switch
Why teams leave Recharge
The reasons that come up most when businesses move from Recharge to MemberZone.
Their business runs through a physical POS, not only an online store.
They would rather avoid monthly plus per-order fees.
They want memberships and loyalty at the point of sale.
Switching
Moving from Recharge
For merchants with a physical store, MemberZone moves recurring revenue to the POS with no monthly platform fee, and runs beside your Shopify store.
- 1Keep your POS and Shopify store. MemberZone connects to your register and runs its own storefront beside Shopify for signups and member orders. Orders placed in Shopify are not synced.
- 2Import your existing members, tiers, and paid-through dates from a spreadsheet during onboarding. Members add a card through a branded link, or, if your old platform charged through Stripe, Stripe can copy their saved cards over.
- 3Turn on dues and rewards. Member discounts apply on their own on Square and Lightspeed. Toast, Shift4, and Clover list rewards for staff to apply.
Pricing
MemberZone
On Starter and Growth there is no monthly platform fee. You pay a percentage of membership and loyalty volume processed: 2.8% on Starter, dropping to 2.4% on Growth. Everyday POS sales are not counted. High-volume programs move to a flat monthly Enterprise rate based on revenue and member count.
Recharge
From ~$99/mo + 1.49% + ~$0.19/order on the Starter tier, scaling up; confirm current rates with Recharge.
Recharge pricing last verified June 2026. Confirm current pricing on the Recharge website before deciding.
Frequently asked questions
Is MemberZone a Recharge alternative?
For in-person and omnichannel merchants, yes. MemberZone runs memberships, subscriptions, and loyalty at the POS with no monthly fee. For pure-online Shopify subscriptions, Recharge is the better fit.
Does MemberZone work with Shopify like Recharge?
Not directly. MemberZone runs beside Shopify with its own storefront, and Shopify orders are not synced to MemberZone. It connects natively to Toast, Square, Lightspeed, Shift4, and Clover. If your program is primarily online Shopify subscriptions, a Shopify-specialist app like Recharge is the better fit.
The shortlist
Other Recharge alternatives
An honest read of the rest of the shortlist, and who each one is best for.
Loop Subscriptions
Independent Shopify subscription app with strong cancellation and retention flows and no per-order fee.
Best for: Online Shopify brands focused on churn recovery
Stay AI
Retention-engineering platform with machine-learning cancel flows for larger DTC brands.
Best for: Scaling online brands optimizing subscriber LTV
Smartrr
Budget-friendly Shopify subscriptions with a clean subscriber portal.
Best for: Small to mid-size online brands on a budget
More comparisons
MemberZone vs Submatic
Submatic nails Square subscription billing. MemberZone wraps a CRM, loyalty, and fulfillment around it.
MemberZone vs Square Loyalty
Square's points-only loyalty add-on: about $45/mo, and locked to Square.
MemberZone vs Commerce7
The modern all-in-one winery DTC suite (club, ecommerce, POS, CRM), priced by revenue with a per-sale platform fee.